Nonprofits can benefit from a steady funding source by introducing nonprofit membership programs. Under this model, individuals pay a recurring fee to access the features and value that an organization creates.
Nonprofit membership programs offer many advantages and are worth the effort to develop and implement. Let’s discuss the benefits of membership programs for organizations, ideas for membership benefits, and how to launch a nonprofit membership program successfully.
Benefits of a membership program
There are plenty of benefits to a membership program tailored to your nonprofit. Here are a few you may notice once your program is in place:
Build a recurring stream of funding
One pain point this relieves is the ongoing challenge of retaining your donor base. With a strong membership program, members will be billed each month or year automatically. The focus on building loyalty or requesting donations again can lessen for this set of donors because the rewards and benefits that come with nonprofit membership programs are built with that foundation in mind.
Tap into the monthly membership trend
The monthly membership trend has become increasingly popular. Outside of the nonprofit industry, the monthly recurring goods and services industry includes everything from pet supplies, makeup, and clothing to shaving products and meal kits.
The growth of this industry is partly driven by the peace of mind that comes from handling recurring needs automatically each month. Combining this concept with the mindset that people naturally want to give and be a part of a bigger cause, building the philosophy of nonprofit membership programs comes naturally.
People want to be part of a bigger mission that they believe in. The perk of the membership program is that supporters are continuously part of your organization’s growth and success.
Create opportunities for consistent communication
Supporters who join nonprofit membership programs truly believe in your organization’s cause and mission. These members are your inner circle, and you need to treat them as such.
This is why the program is a great reason to keep in constant communication with your members. Members want to hear from you as the organization grows with new programs and developments.
Showing members how their contributions make a difference helps build long-term loyalty and support. Some organizations call their monthly members Friends, Inner Circle, or something unique that calls out this special relationship.
Measuring membership program success with KPIs
Tracking key performance indicators (KPIs) is essential to understanding how well your nonprofit membership program is performing. By monitoring these metrics, you can identify strengths, uncover areas for improvement, and make data-driven decisions to grow donations and engagement.
- Member acquisition: Track how many new members join each month. This shows the effectiveness of your outreach campaigns and the clarity of your sign-up process.
- Member retention: Measure the percentage of members who renew monthly or annually. High retention indicates loyalty and satisfaction, while low retention highlights areas needing improvement.
- Tier upgrades: Monitor how many members move to higher tiers or increase their contribution. This demonstrates the appeal of tiered benefits and the growth of recurring donations.
- Revenue growth: Track total income generated from membership fees over time. This helps assess financial sustainability and the success of membership tiers.
- Engagement metrics: Review how often members open newsletters, attend events, or use their benefits. Engagement is a strong indicator of loyalty and long-term support.
- Lifetime value: Calculate the average revenue a member generates during their membership. This informs fundraising forecasts and marketing strategies to optimize donor value.
- Feedback and satisfaction: Collect member feedback through surveys or polls. Understanding satisfaction levels helps refine program features and enhance member experience.
Building your membership program model
Now that we understand the benefits of membership programs for nonprofits, let’s discuss the membership program model. When creating a membership program and presenting your benefits to prospective members, you should always be clear on your value as an organization and what benefits you will provide to members.
Monthly membership tiers
Monthly membership programs are typically offered in membership tiers. This means that there can be several membership options that differ in price, benefits, and rewards.
The benefit of offering several tiers is that a nonprofit organization can serve both ends: giving potential members an option that fits their budget and giving others the option to donate more than the average donor.Membership tiers may range from $10 to $20 on the lower end to around $100 per month on the upper end.
Consider offering rewards and benefits at each tier to encourage members to choose higher membership levels. If you don’t have the bandwidth to support multiple levels, that’s fine too.
Offer annual payment options
While monthly membership programs typically offer packages by the month, another way to pique a potential member’s interest is by offering an annual membership fee discount. Rather than relying only on monthly recurring billing, you can offer members a discount for paying for a full year upfront. This is an especially attractive option on #GivingTuesday and around year-end giving. The benefit for the nonprofit organization is that you secure a year’s worth of donations all at once, for a small discount.
Manage monthly memberships with built-in recurring donation tools
That sounds great, right? But how are you going to manage monthly memberships? You need a recurring donation management system that allows donors to sign up online for monthly or annual recurring donation payments.
After you launch your monthly giving program, add this monthly giving as an option to all your fundraising materials: giving forms, donor envelopes, email announcements, newsletters, and your organization’s website.
Creating rewards and benefits for your members
While many donors give for altruistic reasons, offering rewards and benefits is an important way to grow their loyalty and build their relationship with your organization. Here are some rewards and benefits to consider including at each tier of membership programs for nonprofits.
Store or program discounts
If your nonprofit organization sells accessories or custom products, a member perk can include offering store discounts on all purchases. Offering a 10-20% discount to members can also help your organization sell more. Such discounts can also be offered if your nonprofit organization hosts any educational programs, courses, or classes.
Learn more about nonprofit merchandise sales and our free online stores for nonprofits.
Fundraising event-oriented benefits
Since nonprofit events are often one of the backbones of fundraising, many benefits can be offered around the events hosted by the organization. Such benefits include:
- Discounts for event tickets
- VIP status for signature event tickets
- Exclusive event invitations for members only
- Early bird discount access
Swag or promotional gifts
Everyone loves freebies and gifts. As a token of appreciation for becoming a member, giving swag or promotional gifts to new members is one way to say thank you. Promotional gifts can include tote bags, apparel, key chains, jewelry, or other items that highlight your organization’s brand. However, be mindful of the capacity to fulfill this type of perk.
Exclusive updates or newsletters
While sending newsletters is a good practice for all nonprofit organizations, one can be created specifically for members. The newsletter can include exclusive discounts, gifts, or updates that pertain to the members. Some member-specific updates may be news on a certain program, student, animal, or another recipient that their membership supports.
For your general newsletter and social media channels, use member experiences as testimonials for your broader audience of supporters. For example, ask members to share their reasons why they decided to become a member.
This can be impactful content to add to targeted Facebook or website ads for demographics interested in philanthropy, as well.
Recurring greetings
While this is not necessarily a benefit or perk, it is a helpful strategy in maintaining donor loyalty. Request members’ birthdays so that the nonprofit organization can send a birthday greeting and a thank-you note for their continued support.
Even sending digital or physical greeting cards during the holidays is another way to show that their donation matters and your organization appreciates them as a member.
Parting thoughts on nonprofit membership programs
With some planning and careful execution, nonprofit membership programs can give a substantial boost to your fundraising goals. Membership programs for nonprofits offer advantages such as growing a consistent stream of donations and building donor loyalty.
Contact us to learn more about how to take advantage of integrating nonprofit membership programs into your organization’s website.
FAQs on nonprofit memberships
Yes. Small nonprofits can launch a membership program without a large team or budget. DoJiggy allows quick setup to start generating recurring revenue and deeper supporter engagement.
Set fees that match your mission and audience. Start with a low tier to attract members, then offer higher tiers with clear benefits to encourage more contributions.
Send a personal, warm welcome explaining what members can expect. Highlight benefits and express appreciation to make the first impression meaningful.
Members pay recurring dues for access to exclusive benefits, services, or community. This provides predictable revenue and strengthens engagement with your mission.
Offer tiered memberships, perks, and rewards, host events, and use referral programs. DoJiggy simplifies tracking, management, and recurring payments for growth.
Related Resources
